Joined
·
62 Posts
Not sure if folks have seen this, but here's a picture of the "peening" problem. I have an older model I guess, as mine is the old version -- 370-01xxx
Early LCP Peening
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Joined
·
2,499 Posts
Re: The "Peening" Problem....pictures
Zach, in the 2009 "Concealed Carry Handguns" review of the LCP by Dennis Prisbrey, he speaks to the peening issue specific to the very early run of LCP's including the original test gun he received from Ruger, his replacement LCP (with mod incorporated) had no peening problem whatsoever. The corner taking the peening has since been relieved by about a 1/8-inch square cut removing that section of the frame from any impact. What was happening was that the extractor was throwing empty cases to the rear with quite a bit of force, and the rims were impacting the frame corner with enough oomph to cause the extractor to tear into the rim before the ejector could throw the cases out of the ejection port. That caused wild ejection and frame peening.
Zach, in the 2009 "Concealed Carry Handguns" review of the LCP by Dennis Prisbrey, he speaks to the peening issue specific to the very early run of LCP's including the original test gun he received from Ruger, his replacement LCP (with mod incorporated) had no peening problem whatsoever. The corner taking the peening has since been relieved by about a 1/8-inch square cut removing that section of the frame from any impact. What was happening was that the extractor was throwing empty cases to the rear with quite a bit of force, and the rims were impacting the frame corner with enough oomph to cause the extractor to tear into the rim before the ejector could throw the cases out of the ejection port. That caused wild ejection and frame peening.
Joined
·
62 Posts
Re: The "Peening" Problem....pictures
I wonder if we should send our two back to Ruger for repair?
What to folks think? ???
I wonder if we should send our two back to Ruger for repair?
What to folks think? ???
Joined
·
2,499 Posts
Re: The "Peening" Problem....pictures
Zach, your decision but I would call Ruger and let us know what they say. Typically with peening, it reaches a certain point and stops. And it's not interfering with the functioning of the gun correct? It doesn't seem so from your videos.
Zach, your decision but I would call Ruger and let us know what they say. Typically with peening, it reaches a certain point and stops. And it's not interfering with the functioning of the gun correct? It doesn't seem so from your videos.
Re: The "Peening" Problem....pictures
#2 Every kt made and they made a couple hundred thousand of them peened in that same exact area. Kt, never replaced or even changed the mod. they just stated, take a file and file it down and it will soon stop.
#3 It will stop
#4 take a small file and file that little peened burr off and put some flat black on that area and just keep an eye on it, once the flat black preceeds to not wear off, you have done enough.
#5, should Ruger have caught that area, yup indeed. Does it hurt anything. ABSOLUTELY NOT.
#6 would I send mine in, NO, un less it had another issue with it that required Rugers services.
#7, If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
#8 Just shoot it like youy stole it
#1. I doubt if Ruger will issue a prepaid pickup for ur two lcps that don't have that mod done to them.Zach and Holly said:
#2 Every kt made and they made a couple hundred thousand of them peened in that same exact area. Kt, never replaced or even changed the mod. they just stated, take a file and file it down and it will soon stop.
#3 It will stop
#4 take a small file and file that little peened burr off and put some flat black on that area and just keep an eye on it, once the flat black preceeds to not wear off, you have done enough.
#5, should Ruger have caught that area, yup indeed. Does it hurt anything. ABSOLUTELY NOT.
#6 would I send mine in, NO, un less it had another issue with it that required Rugers services.
#7, If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
#8 Just shoot it like youy stole it
Joined
·
2,499 Posts
Re: The "Peening" Problem....pictures
If you do what Jocko suggested, basically just smooth out the rough spots (with a fine file, I like to to use a fine Arkansas stone if I can) you will end up essentially with the factory mod. It may not look quite as "purty" but essentially it's the same result. To reiterate, peening reaches a certain point and tends to stop and there is peening and there is peening. The wear in your case in no way interferes with the functioning of the gun, are we correct? I'd say it falls more under the heading of a superficial wound. I'd still (just for your peace of mind) call Ruger and see if they are willing to provide any assistance. Why not. If it was me though and the gun/s work fine othewise, I would just do a little polishing/filingor stoning and leave it alone.
If you do what Jocko suggested, basically just smooth out the rough spots (with a fine file, I like to to use a fine Arkansas stone if I can) you will end up essentially with the factory mod. It may not look quite as "purty" but essentially it's the same result. To reiterate, peening reaches a certain point and tends to stop and there is peening and there is peening. The wear in your case in no way interferes with the functioning of the gun, are we correct? I'd say it falls more under the heading of a superficial wound. I'd still (just for your peace of mind) call Ruger and see if they are willing to provide any assistance. Why not. If it was me though and the gun/s work fine othewise, I would just do a little polishing/filingor stoning and leave it alone.
Joined
·
62 Posts
Thanks! Funny enough, Holly's gun has the mod -- mine doesn't. Dohhh....
Joined
·
201 Posts
The pictures you are using were taken and first posted by me on RugerForum. Here are the original sized pics for easy viewing....Zach and Holly said:
As for the peening issue, after calling Joe Crammer at Ruger back in March, I took my LCP to the factory in Prescott and they re-milled the area while I waited (they also threw in two free mags). He advised me in the future they would not re-mill unless it was causing a problem. Although they made an adjustment to the production process, Ruger considers the peening to be a cosmetic issue only in the earlier LCP's.Zach and Holly said:
As suggested above, a call to Ruger is in order if you are considering sending yours back. Let us know what they say....
Joined
·
62 Posts
Is that your gun "re-milled"? If it is, looks nice.
I've had a few wild ejections, they shoot up and straight back. Not sure if I should call or not...
I've had a few wild ejections, they shoot up and straight back. Not sure if I should call or not...
Joined
·
201 Posts
Yes, the LCP AND pics are mine, minus the notations you must have added... first posted on RugerForumZach and Holly said:
Joined
·
43 Posts
You could find a local hobby machinist, that would take about five minutes to set up in a mill and just a touch with a 1/8 inch cutter to fix, I'd fix ya up if you were around here.
Joined
·
99 Posts
I just picked up an Elsie today. The serial number is 370-60XXX and is has been milled. The case fire date is 10/03/08.
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
