Ruger Pistol Forums banner
1 - 3 of 3 Posts

·
Premium Member
My favorite firearm will always be my Ruger Standard with sights painted white by my grandfather
Joined
·
207 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·

Many gun enthusiasts will scoff at carrying a .32 Auto or .380 Auto.

They'll make claims about not having as much knockdown power as larger calibers; while their claims are accurate, these same individuals often overlook the benefits of small caliber pistols.

That's why we're going to compare the 32 ACP vs. 380 ACP, so each caliber gets a fair evaluation.

After you've finished this article, you'll know if you should purchase either caliber. If so, which one is best for you?

.32 ACP vs .380 ACP
John Moses Browning created both calibers within a decade of each other for similar reasons, and they're similar in size.

So we shouldn't expect that much difference between the two calibers.

Let's find out just how different they are.

Cartridge Specs
The .32 Auto bullet measures between .308" and .3125". The bullet sits in a .680" long semi-rimmed straight-walled case. Which means the overall cartridge length comes in just under an inch at 0.984".

In Europe, they call the .32 ACP the 7.65mm Browning. It's designed for semi-auto handguns and has been chambered in more guns than any other cartridge in history.

.380 ammo is a rimless straight-walled case with a bullet weight of 85-95gr and a bullet diameter of .355". The cartridge's overall length is 0.984".

It's no surprise that these two cartridges look nearly identical, with the primary difference being the rim diameters of 0.358" for the .32 ACP cartridge and 0.374" for the .380 ACP cartridge. So if you decide to get both, be sure to pay attention to which one you're loading into what gun.

.380 vs. .32: Recoil
Recoil is determined most by the amount of powder, bullet weight, gun weight, and the shooter.

It's important to consider because some people are more sensitive to recoil than others. This can make them less accurate and slower on follow-up shots, which could be costly during a self-defense situation.

As a child, I would flinch before I pulled the trigger because I was anticipating the recoil, making me less accurate and slower to send the next round downrange.

Thankfully, I outgrew this bad habit due in part to downsizing calibers and then working my way back up to larger calibers with more recoil.

Both calibers were designed for a small pocket pistol, so neither packs a punch and the primary reason many smaller framed individuals prefer to shoot .380 ACP vs. 9mm.

I love shooting my 9mm Smith & Wesson Shield. However, my wife found it to be too much felt recoil for her, so we bought her a .380 Auto pistol, and she loves it.

Comparing the recoil of these two calibers is nothing like comparing the 9mm vs. .45 ACP. The recoil difference between the .380 ACP vs. .32 ACP is minimal.

Since we need a winner, the .32 ACP will have less recoil than the .380 ACP because it shoots lighter bullets.

Trajectory
Neither of these pistol calibers was intended for long-distance shooting, so the trajectory of both is unimpressive.

However, there have been a few attempts to use machine guns chambered in the .380 ACP. They were intended for close combat, but the extra barrel length slightly extends the range of the .380 Auto.

Since these calibers are primarily for self or home defense, you shouldn't need to worry about the trajectory because most of these scenarios happen well within 25 yards, and the .32 ACP is still flat shooting at that distance.

This section is a tie.

Accuracy
The gun and the shooter primarily determine accuracy. Most shooters will find they are more accurate with specific guns than others. Recoil also affects accuracy to a degree.

As you know, accuracy is crucial because you need to be able to hit the target at which you're aiming. This is for your safety and the safety of those around you.

It's for your safety because the more accurate you are, the quicker you can stop a threat, and it's for the protection of others because you're bullets will be hitting the target instead of people near the danger.

An average shooter will be very accurate with the .380 Auto or the .32 Auto because the low recoil of both calibers contributes to increased accuracy. The accuracy of follow-up shots at close distances is also higher with both calibers.

Therefore, this category is also a tie.

.32 vs. .380: Stopping Power
The stopping power of both calibers is relatively weak.

However, stopping power is an overrated metric.

Now let me explain before you call in the calvary!

A .22 LR bullet in the vitals will stop someone faster than a .45 ACP bullet in the hand. So shot placement is critical.

With that said a poorly placed .45 ACP round will do more damage than a poorly placed .22 LR. That's why many people compromise and choose to carry a 9mm or .380 Auto, but most overlook the .32 Auto.

There is no scientific process to determine stopping power; however, the general rule of thumb is that the larger the bullet, the more stopping power it has because it leaves a bigger hole and it's heavier.

The bullets are very similar when shooting ballistics gelatin, except the .380 bullet leaves a slightly larger hole because of its larger diameter. It also travels deeper into the ballistics gel because it has more mass, so it will take more force to stop it.

The bullet type also factors into this equation. A jacketed hollow point (JHP) will cause more damage than a full metal jacket (FMJ) because the JHP expands and fragments which cause more damage, therefore, more stopping power.

With all things as equal as possible, the .380 ACP bullet has more stopping power than the .32 ACP bullet.

The .380 ACP ammo wins this round.

Hunting
For most hunting scenarios, you'll want a rifle caliber; however, if you're determined to hunt with a handgun, I suggest stepping up to a large round like a .44 Magnum.

The .32 Auto and the .380 Auto can be used to hunt small game like rabbits and other small varmints, but their projectiles don't have the knockdown power to ethically harvest anything larger than a groundhog from any considerable distance.

The .380 ACP snake shot ammo is an excellent round for small reptiles and rodents like rats.

Even carrying either of these calibers in a backup gun isn't advised by big-game hunters.

The .32 ACP and .380 ACP are powerful enough to put down a suffering animal humanely, they both require well-placed shots, and you're unlikely to have an opportunity to take a well-placed shot if you're using either one as a backup.

That's why it's best to stick with more powerful rounds for all hunting situations. However, if I were forced to choose between these calibers to go hunting with, I would choose the .380 Automatic Colt Pistol.

.32 ACP vs. .380 ACP: Self-Defense & Home Defense
I feel like I've repeated myself several times, saying, "these calibers weren't designed with this in mind."

Well, that stops now.

Self-defense and home defense are precisely why these calibers were created.

Despite what many claim, both calibers shine in concealed carry situations. They're often chambered in small, easily concealable hammerless pistols and have a decent magazine capacity.

As we've already discussed, the primary drawback of using these calibers for self-defense is their lack of firepower, but that shouldn't discount them from the discussion because stopping power isn't everything.

My wife's go-to gun for concealed carry or home defense is her Kimber chambered in .380 Auto ammo because it has low recoil, and the small frame fits her hands well; she would be much more reluctant to pull the trigger of my .45 Auto, plus it's difficult for her to grip correctly.

Another reason why you should consider the .32 ACP or .380 ACP as a viable self and home defense round is that they're less likely to penetrate walls, which means your family and neighbors are safer from friendly fire.

I still prefer my 12 gauge or 20 gauge shotguns for home defense over my pistols to help cut down on the chance of harming an innocent bystander.

For concealed carry purposes, I prefer to have a .380 ACP in my waistband over a .32 ACP because it has greater knockdown power and the same amount of round capacity as most .32 Auto pistols.

The winner of this section is the .380 Auto.

Ammo Cost & Availability
The cost of ammo has skyrocketed in the last several years while the availability has plummeted.

Economics 101, when supply is low and demand is high, the price goes up.

It's pointless to purchase a gun that's chambered for a round that's impossible to buy unless you're into really cool paperweights.

However, if you like me and prefer to shoot your gun, I suggest purchasing firearms in standard calibers like .32 Auto and .380 Auto.

The drawback is that many other people have these calibers, so when demand increases, they're usually one of the first rounds people grab. This also means they're one of the first that ammo manufacturers begin making, so supplies shouldn't be low for long.

While the .32 Browning Auto is older and chambered in more handguns than any other caliber, it's begun to decline in popularity; therefore, ammo makers don't manufacture it as much as they do .380 ammo.

Surprisingly .32 ACP ammo is cheaper than .380 ammunition in most instances. The price of ammo for .32 ACP caliber guns varies depending on bullet type and brand but expect to pay at least $0.60 per round. Because it is declining in popularity, the ammo is becoming more challenging to find compared to .380.

You can find .380 ACP ammo for as cheap as $0.50 per round; however, you're more likely to find it in the $1- $1.50 per round range, especially if you're looking for self-defense ammo.

Since this caliber is more popular, it has a broader selection of bullet types and loads. Most ammo manufacturers like Remington, Federal, Cor-Bon, Fiocchi, Speer, Blazer, and Hornady produce ammo for the .380 ACP.

I give the edge to the .380 Auto for this category because it's easier to find ammo, and it's not much more expensive.

Gun Cost & Availability
If you're like me, then you don't have an unlimited budget for firearms; otherwise, I'd need a much larger safe!

That often means I'm searching for good deals when buying my next gun, and the price tends to be a significant factor in convincing my wife that I need this gun.

If a gun is hard to find, then the price will increase. I tried to keep this in mind while researching both calibers.

Many shooters love the Ruger LCP, which is chambered in .380 Auto because it's lightweight, easy to conceal, and inexpensive. Depending on the upgrades you wish to add, you'll be able to pick one up for around $300.

Several other popular pistols chambered in .380, like the Glock 43, Sig Sauger P238, Walther PK38, and the Kel-Tec P-3AT. Each varies in price, but most are readily available.

As far as guns chambered in .32 Auto goes, there are several to choose from, like the Beretta Tomcat, Kel-Tec P-32, and the North American Arms Guardian .32 ACP pistol. These also vary in price, but you should expect to pay a similar amount for a .32 ACP handgun as you would for a .380 ACP gun.

This section is a tie because the availability of the guns and the costs are so similar.

Reloading the .380 ACP Vs .32 ACP
Reloading is one of the best ways to save money on ammunition and control the controllable variables.

Some rounds are better suited for handloading than others. For instance, the .22 LR is difficult to handload because it's a rimless cartridge.

That's not the case for the .380 Auto or the .32 Auto. They both are straight-walled centerfire cartridges which makes them ideal for reloading. The bullets are reasonably abundant and common, and depending on which powder and primers you choose, they shouldn't be difficult to find.

The reloading equipment is readily available, which means if you're making your decision solely based on reloading, it's a close call.

The one advantage the .380 has would be that it uses the same bullet as the 9mm. This is good because a lot of companies will manufacture it, but it also means that lots of reloaders want that bullet, so demand for it is also high.

The .380 is the more popular round, so, in theory, the reloading supplies should be more abundant. Therefore, we will give the narrow victory to the .380 Automatic Colt Pistol.

.32 Auto History
The .32 Automatic Colt Pistol cartridge traces its origins back to John Moses Browning. In 1899 he designed this cartridge for the Fabrique Nationale 1900 blowback pistol.

In 1903, the Colt Model 1903 Pocket Pistol hit the market in the US, which only helped increase its popularity. It's no surprise that other firearms manufacturers began releasing their semi-automatic pistols chambered in .32 ACP.

The .32 ACP was carried by law enforcement and militaries around the world. It's also played its part in assassinations, suicides, and movies. This caliber was popular for several reasons, good and bad.

.380 Auto History
Not surprisingly, the .380 ACP also traces its origins back to John Moses Browning. In 1908 the Colt Model 1908 Pocket Pistol was released, chambered in .380 ACP.

In 1912, when it was introduced in Belgium, it became known as the 9mm short. It remained popular through World War II and was the primary pistol caliber for militaries worldwide until the 9mm replaced it.

There are a few countries where the .380 ACP is still the official military pistol cartridge.

Final Shots: 380 vs. 32 ACP
If I've said it once, I've said it a thousand times; these rounds are very similar. However, the differences show why John Browning created the .380 ACP.

He definitely improved upon his original design. It's hard to argue with over 100 years of use, and it shows no signs of going away anytime soon.

While I would choose the .380 over the .32 ACP, there are a few instances when the .32 ACP should be the caliber you choose. If recoil is your primary concern, or you want to pretend you're James Bond while carrying a Walther PPK.

Otherwise, when comparing the 32 ACP vs 380 ACP, you should choose the .380 Automatic Colt Pistol.

Continue reading 32 ACP vs 380 ACP: The Automatic Colt Pistol Rivalry on Ammo.com for comparative ballistic data!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RICHGCOOP

·
Registered
Joined
·
40 Posts
You have to carry the biggest firearm you can carry. That depends upon your circumstances.


The 32 ACP is a special round... it has a modest rim, I've been told because it was intended for revolvers as well as self loaders. The round has low pressure, peaking at roughly 20,500 psi. The 32 ACP has a low charge weight, which makes suppression easier. Normally bullet grain weight is 71 grains.

There have been observations that the 32 ACP is prone to locking on the rims in a magazine.

The 380 ACP is rimless. Peak pressure a little bit more than the 32 acp, about 21,500. Normally bullet weight is around 95 grains. The 380 has a base similar to the 223 (not the same but close) and shares the ease for staggered column magazines.


Polite reminder - the Soviets shot roughly 22,000 Polish elites with Walther 2 25 ACP handguns. One shot each, every ninety seconds, for ten hours a night. Shot placement counts for a lot. The SS at Trebelinka managed prisoners using 380 ACP and 32 ACPs, thousands of them, at their phony "hospital". One "pill" to each condemned, with a "neck shot". The Auschwitz some SS began to use air rifles aiming at the base of the skull.

Shot placement really does count for a lot.





 
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Top